Canandaigua's Leading Coin Shop

Old & new coins, foreign and U.S., rare collector’s coins, proof sets & much more!

Cash For Your Silver & Gold!

We buy silver & gold as well as jewelry. Stop in for an honest & professional appraisal.

Magic the Gathering Cards

We buy, sell & trade Magic boosters, bundles and decks – stop in for tournaments too!

Collectible Currency

We stock a wide variety of rare US paper money!

Coins

Do you have a coin or currency collection gathering dust that might be worth something? Take it to Smitty’s to find out!

Smitty’s fully appraises and explains the real value of your coins and gold. Unlike the many “we buy your gold shops” that have popped up, Smitty’s has over thirty years of experience.

Stop in to buy, sell or trade your coins, currency, bullion gold or silver! We also buy scrap gold and jewelry.

Cards

Smitty’s is the place in Canandaigua for the events (Magic the Gathering, Disney Lorcana, and Flesh and Blood) along with a variety of Pokemon and Dungeons and Dragons books and supplies

We buy, sell, and trade Magic, Lorcana, and Pokemon cards, packs, and supplies. We have a regular supply and variety of Boosters, Bundles, and Decks.

Please click on the Events link here or above for more info – we have events Friday nights and Saturday @ Noon!